User talk:WikiCantona/20070530115619
Details matter[編輯]
- 有嘢講：/Comment：
That depends on how the texts were written. The detailed accusations toward named individuals must be sourced. The current text written by me has been avoid all the specific mention of names and details that could identify the individual. The details should leave to the cited sources (if there is any).
Also, be very careful with using this Living Person deletion. Let say, there is organization X being critique for its position on Y, If you push along, the organiztion X must be headed by someone, made up with some individuals, By applying to the Living person criteria, all critiques could be removed. We don't want that, right ?! What if it is a tradition for the organization to do Y, it is a pattern, rather than person's doing. Of course, cited sources should be provided.
Whether to delete something or not cannot simply by citing some policies. Sometime they are judgement calls - not simply a clear-cut, black and white issue when coming to written text.
I will remove the paragraph in that article if no reliable sources are cited in one more day.